Skip to main content

The Box or the Chocolates?

I believe it was Vance Packard, in his seminal book, The Hidden Persuaders that told the story of how Whitman© Chocolates used to spend more on developing and producing the box in which the chocolates were sold then on the chocolates themselves. The packaging was more important then the chocolates to selling the product. Human nature? Perhaps. A sustainable solution? No.

Think Lindt ® chocolates.

This same myopic approach seems to be driving the discussion about Container security and monitoring solutions. The technology discussion is trumping the business imperative. Truth is, after determining the technologies reliability, flexibility and ease of use, users -- the 3PLs and their clients, the consignees -- don’t care about the engineering or hardware.

Think iPod®.

The optimal container monitoring solution recognizes:

  • The box (Container) is not important: it’s the goods inside the Container that matters
  • The truck or Vessel that delivers the goods is not important: it’s the goods in the box’s on the truck or Vessel that matters
  • The cost of the box is not material, the cost of the cargo is


Net net ,,, it’s the contents that matter, not the box, not the vessel, not the truck and not the technology. The monitoring industry needs to recognize that importers and exporters will not adopt a solution that’s proprietary, infrastructure dependent, inflexible, complex or expensive.

The importers and exporters will adopt a monitoring technology that is:

  • Flexible, portable and reliable
  • Infrastructure free to be deployed globally
  • Interoperable with existing supply chain solutions and client applications
  • Configurable to the clients business requirements
  • Beneficial to the business, reducing costs and improving financial performance


Again, think iPod®.

And think universal, flexible, portable, globally deployable, interoperable, configurable and beneficial.

  • Flexible: monitoring service can work with dry, reefer or tank containers
  • Portable: monitoring device moves to the container, any container, as required
  • Reliable: 99.9% service availability for global track, trace and monitor
  • Globally deployable, infrastructure free, the service follows the cargo, not vice versa
  • Interoperable: monitoring service can be integrated with other technologies (RFID, Bar Code and emerging technologies) and applications, ERP’s, SC solutions and client proprietary applications
  • Configurable: the monitoring service sensors, business events, alerts and reporting has to be client configurable to the requirements for the specific trip.
  • Beneficial: the service must enable clients to recognize real costs savings from the supply chain, thereby improving overall financial performance.


Any monitoring service that is dependent on the container (the box), difficult to deploy globally because of a dependency of external infrastructure, layers on an incompatible application, and fails to produce financially beneficial results, won’t be adopted by the logistics industry or their clients, the consignees.

For proof of this assertion, look at the existing adoption rate of deployed container monitoring solutions, it won’t take you long.

(by Arthur Radford)

iPod® is a trademark of Apple Corporation.
Lindt® is a trademark of Lindt & Sprungli

Comments

peter said…
Yes, I agree with you. The goods are more important than their containers. The business will result in a loss if it gives more importance to the package than on improving the quality of its products. The Supply Chain Management Services should consider improving the goods to see an increase in the business.
Just the opposite, Cadbury, recently announced that it is not shipping its famous chocolate Easter Eggs in boxes, but rather just using the foil wrapping.

Also on a different subject Supply Chain Management Review just published an interesting article on smart containers. http://www.scmr.com/article/CA6518145.html

Popular posts from this blog

Networked Supply Chains Require Better Visibility

As manufactures and retailers increasingly depend on extended rosters of sourcing companies, the resulting networked supply chain requires improved visibility. Importers are using multiple sourcing vendors to improve their ability to respond to market demand and opportunities. With this increased sourcing agility comes the increased risk of delivery failure due to a supply chain disruption and, concurrently, the increased importance of visibility into each step of the supply chain. The ability to in real time identify the location and status of the sourced goods gives the importer the ability to fine tune its distribution channels, its inventory management and its ability to fulfill commitments to its end users. The ability to real time monitor the status of goods requires a combination of container based technology, back-end business applications and an extended network of logistics fulfillment partners. In response to this emerging demand, many companies are offering RFID, GSM and si

The Vicious Cycle of Supply-Chain Innovation - Trapped Between Inflation and Interest Rates

  Although headline inflation has fallen in most economies in recent months, core inflation remains stubbornly high. During times of high inflation, the cost of goods and services often increases rapidly, putting a strain on a business's finances. As a result, many business leaders may focus on cost management strategies, such as reducing expenses and cutting back on investments, to maintain profitability. Unfortunately, this can make it challenging to prioritize supply chain optimization. Supply chain optimization can be a highly effective strategy to alleviate the impact of high inflation. However, it is crucial to understand that supply chain optimization can be a highly effective strategy, especially during times of high inflation, and can help alleviate the impact of high inflation on their finances. By streamlining and improving the efficiency of supply chain processes, businesses can achieve long-term cost savings and improved profitability. Optimizing the supply chain can h

India: A rising giant in the world of supply chain management!!

  India is one of the fastest-growing economies in the world. The growth in real GDP during 2022-23 is estimated at 7.2 percent compared to 9.1 percent in 2021-22, according to data released by India's Central Statistics Office (CSO). Boasting a robust economy and favorable demographics, it's no wonder many international companies are eyeing India as a prime location to set up their manufacturing facilities and supply chains. As this trend continues, the demand for supply chain management in India is expected to soar. The thriving economy and burgeoning consumer market have created a wealth of new growth opportunities, but they also present unique challenges for companies operating in India. To succeed in this dynamic market, it's essential to understand these challenges and how to overcome them. By doing so, businesses can position themselves for success and tap into India's immense potential. According to official estimates, India's population is set to reach a st